I only have the one but can recommend... The Sportsheets love heart paddle.

It's a black leather paddle with 3 cut out love hearts on one side, it leaves the love heart shapes on the skin after spanking too!

Used on my girlfriend and had it used on me so can say it's good to use and feels good being spanked with.

Hope this helps - but like I say, I cannot really make any comparisons with any other product.

Plus, it was the cheapest on sale at approx. £15 from SexShop365.